The Current State of Democracy in South America: A Country-by-Country Analysis

Image Source: AI Generated

South America’s democratic landscape has undergone dramatic shifts in the past decade, with some nations strengthening their democratic institutions while others face increasing authoritarian pressures. These changes have reshaped the political fabric of a continent that spent much of the 20th century struggling to establish stable democracies.

The region presents a complex mosaic of democratic systems, each with unique challenges and achievements. From Brazil’s massive electoral system to Uruguay’s stable democratic institutions, every country tells a different story about the state of democracy in the 21st century.

This comprehensive analysis examines the current state of democracy across South American nations, evaluating their electoral systems, judicial independence, civil liberties, and economic factors. We’ll explore how these elements interact to either strengthen or weaken democratic institutions in each country, providing a clear picture of where democracy stands in South America today.

Democratic Performance Rankings in South America

Recent assessments of democratic institutions reveal significant variations in performance across South American nations. According to Freedom House’s latest evaluation, 70% of people in the Americas live in Free countries, while 6% reside in Not Free countries [1].

Freedom House and Democracy Matrix Scores

Uruguay stands as the region’s strongest democracy, achieving a perfect score in electoral process and pluralism (10.0) and high marks in civil liberties (9.71) [2]. The Democracy Matrix rankings position Chile (0.84) and Uruguay (0.847) among the top performers in South America [3]. However, a concerning trend shows that Venezuela ranks at the bottom with a liberal democracy index of just 0.064 [4].

Top Performing Democracies Score Uruguay 0.847 Chile 0.840 Argentina 0.763 Trends in Democratic Quality (2018-2023)

The region has experienced a notable democratic decline over the past five years, with key developments including:

• Increased militarization of government in countries like Chile, Ecuador, and Peru [5]
• Declining press freedom, with 10 countries showing deterioration in Freedom of Expression [5]
• Growing challenges to judicial independence and anti-corruption efforts [5]

Regional Comparisons and Benchmarks

South America presents a complex democratic landscape, with half of the region’s nations performing below the global average [5]. The latest Freedom House assessment indicates that nine countries recorded score declines in 2023, with none showing improvements [1]. Peru experienced the region’s largest democratic regression (-4 points) due to authorities’ excessive use of force against protesters [1].

The Democracy Matrix classifications reveal that most South American nations fall into the “deficient democracy” category, with only Uruguay maintaining its position as a high-performing democracy [3]. This trend reflects broader challenges in maintaining democratic institutions, particularly in areas of accountability and political participation [6].

Electoral Systems and Political Participation

Electoral participation across South America presents a complex picture of democratic engagement, with significant variations in voter turnout and institutional integrity. Recent studies reveal both promising developments and concerning challenges in the region’s electoral systems.

Voter Turnout and Electoral Integrity

Electoral participation remains a critical indicator of democratic health, with age and education emerging as the strongest predictors of voter turnout across the region [7]. Brazil stands out with the largest electoral participation, recording more voter turnout than all other Latin American countries combined [8].

However, electoral integrity faces significant challenges. Vote-buying remains prevalent, with one in four citizens being offered bribes in exchange for votes during national, regional, or local elections [9]. The severity varies by country:

• Mexico leads with 50% of voters offered bribes [9]
• Dominican Republic reports 46% vote-buying incidents [9]
• Brazil and Colombia both show 40% vote-buying rates [9]

Political Party Systems

South American party systems have undergone substantial transformations since the 1980s, characterized by varying levels of institutionalization and stability. The region’s political landscape shows distinct patterns of party competition, with most systems now operating along a single dominant dimension that combines economic and socio-cultural issues [10].

Recent developments indicate that 56% of people believe fake news frequently spreads during elections [9]. Brazil particularly struggles with this issue, where more than three-quarters of the population reports frequent circulation of false information during electoral periods [9].

Campaign Finance and Electoral Reform

Campaign finance regulation remains a critical challenge for democratic integrity in the region. Key findings show:

• 65% of Latin Americans believe their government serves private interests rather than public good [9]
• The Bahamas and Brazil show the highest perception of private interest control (79% and 75% respectively) [9]

To address these challenges, experts recommend several crucial reforms:

1. Establishing transparent campaign finance regulations
2. Enforcing sanctions against vote-buying
3. Creating unified online portals for political funding disclosure [9]

The influence of money in politics poses a particular threat in Latin America due to income inequality and organized crime presence [11]. Well-designed political finance regulations have become essential for ensuring money serves as a positive force in democratic processes rather than a corrupting influence [12].

Judicial Independence and Rule of Law

The judicial landscape across South America reveals a complex interplay between institutional independence and political influence, with significant variations in court system effectiveness and anti-corruption efforts. Recent studies indicate that judicial independence scores range dramatically, from Uruguay’s robust 5.4 to Venezuela’s concerning 1.1 on the World Economic Forum’s scale [13].

Court System Effectiveness

Brazil and Chile stand out as regional leaders in judicial professionalism, implementing merit-based systems for selecting judges and prosecutors. Brazil’s success stems from its 1988 Constitution, which established a technocratic process for judicial appointments [3]. The effectiveness of court systems varies significantly across the region, with key challenges including:

• Limited career track opportunities in most countries except Brazil and Chile
• High percentage of non-tenured judges
• Insufficient expert and funding support
• Inadequate judicial council autonomy [1]

Anti-Corruption Efforts

Anti-corruption initiatives have shown mixed results across the region. Brazil’s Lava Jato investigations led to more than 200 convictions of politicians and business leaders [3]. In Peru, the fallout from corruption scandals resulted in the investigation of three former presidents [1]. However, challenges persist:

The World Justice Project’s Rule of Law Index reveals concerning scores for several nations:

Country Rule of Law Score Venezuela 0.14 Bolivia 0.24 Nicaragua 0.32 Honduras 0.35 [1] Legal Protection of Rights

The Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights reports significant progress in strengthening legal protections across South America. Key developments include:

1. Implementation of technical assistance programs in seven countries for legislation and policies
2. Enhanced capacity-building efforts for judiciary members in Ecuador and Chile
3. Improved support systems for human rights defenders [13]

However, arbitrary detention remains widespread in several countries, with El Salvador recording more than 73,000 arbitrary detentions since March 2022 [3]. The effectiveness of legal protection varies significantly, with Chile and Brazil demonstrating stronger institutional frameworks for protecting citizens’ rights, while Venezuela and Bolivia struggle with maintaining basic legal protections [1].

Recent reforms have shown promise in strengthening judicial independence, particularly in Colombia and Guatemala, where courts have helped protect institutional stability from arbitrary acts of powerful actors [1]. However, the region still faces significant challenges in establishing truly independent judiciary systems that can effectively uphold democratic principles and protect citizens’ rights.

Civil Liberties and Human Rights

Civil liberties and human rights conditions across South America paint a concerning picture of democratic erosion, with significant challenges emerging in press freedom, assembly rights, and minority protections.

Freedom of Expression and Media

Press freedom faces unprecedented challenges across South America, with more than half of the countries experiencing deteriorating conditions in 2024 [14]. The situation is particularly dire for journalists, with Mexico recording 72 journalist deaths in the past decade [14]. Peru has seen one of the most dramatic declines, falling 48 places in press freedom rankings over just two years [14].

Notable Press Freedom Rankings:

Country Global Rank Costa Rica 26th Chile 52nd Argentina 66th Venezuela 156th Assembly and Association Rights

The right to peaceful assembly faces increasing restrictions across the region. In Colombia, police responses to mostly peaceful demonstrations have resulted in excessive force and arbitrary dispersals [15]. Civil society space continues to shrink, with Nicaragua alone revoking the legal status of more than 2,000 NGOs between August 2022 and September 2023 [3].

Key challenges to assembly rights include:

• Criminalization of peaceful protesters in Argentina, Canada, Cuba, and Mexico [3]
• Excessive surveillance of protest organizers
• Restrictions on movement during demonstrations
• Implementation of laws diluting legal protections for protesters

Minority Rights Protection

Indigenous and Afro-descendant communities face disproportionate challenges in exercising their democratic rights. In Colombia, 269 indigenous leaders were killed between 2016 and 2020 [4]. The situation is particularly concerning in regions like Chocó, Antioquia, Cauca, and Norte de Santander, where communities face:

• Forced displacement from ancestral lands
• Limited access to essential services
• Restricted freedom of movement within territories
• Ongoing threats from armed groups

The Truth Commission’s findings highlight how armed conflicts have perpetuated racist and colonial power dynamics, with indigenous and Afro-descendant individuals often subjected to brutal methods of violence [4]. Some positive developments include the appointment of three indigenous people to cabinet positions in Colombia and the historic election of Francia Márquez as the first Black woman Vice-President [4].

Human rights defenders, particularly those working on environmental and land rights issues, remain at severe risk. Latin America recorded 264 killings of human rights defenders in 2020, representing 79% of the global total [16]. Colombia stands as the world’s most dangerous country for these activists, with 177 killings in a single year [16].

Economic Factors Affecting Democracy

The economic landscape of South America presents formidable challenges to democratic stability, with income inequality and corruption emerging as primary threats to institutional integrity. Latin America maintains its position as the world’s most unequal region, with the top 10% of earners making 12 times more than the poorest 10% [17].

Income Inequality Impact

The concentration of wealth has reached alarming levels across the region. In Colombia, Chile, and Uruguay, approximately 1% of the population controls between 37% and 40% of total wealth [18]. This disparity creates a democratic paradox: while the region remains predominantly democratic, the extreme wealth gap undermines institutional effectiveness and public trust.

Economic Distribution in Select Countries:

Country Wealth Control by Top 1% Colombia 40% Chile 38% Uruguay 37% Corruption and Economic Policy

The relationship between corruption and democratic governance has created a troubling cycle. Key impacts include:

• Reduced government capacity to deliver public services [19]
• Misallocation of talent and capital through distorted incentives [19]
• Lower legitimacy of government institutions [19]
• Decreased private and foreign investment [19]

The region ranks third globally in corruption levels, trailing only Africa and the Middle East [17]. This endemic corruption has become particularly damaging as governments struggle with post-pandemic economic recovery, with estimates suggesting it could take a decade to return to pre-pandemic GDP levels [18].

Social Program Effects

Despite these challenges, social assistance programs have shown promise in strengthening democratic institutions. Over the last two decades, most countries initiated and strengthened social assistance programs, addressing long-standing challenges of poverty and inequality [20]. Notable achievements include:

The Dominican Republic’s Integrated Social Protection and Promotion Project demonstrated significant impact, with nearly 150,000 households receiving health-related transfers and 273,000 students receiving education-linked support [20]. The program reduced underweight rates among participating children to 9%, compared to 35% for non-participants [20].

However, the effectiveness of these programs faces constant pressure from economic constraints. Many governments provide subsidies for critical needs like food and fuel, but high inflation and mounting debt payments challenge their ability to maintain these supports [5]. This financial strain has particular significance for democratic stability, as demonstrated in 2019 when a simple public transportation fare increase triggered massive protests in Chile [5].

The middle class, increasingly dissatisfied with the status quo, demands increased social spending, creating a complex challenge for governments attempting to balance social needs with fiscal constraints [17]. This tension is exemplified in Argentina, where the government struggles with 100% inflation while negotiating with the International Monetary Fund [18].

Conclusion

South America’s democratic journey reveals stark contrasts, from Uruguay’s robust institutions to Venezuela’s authoritarian decline. The region’s democratic health faces significant pressures from widespread corruption, economic inequality, and threats to civil liberties. These challenges create a complex web where economic instability feeds political uncertainty, while weak institutions struggle to protect basic rights and freedoms.

Several countries show promising developments through strengthened judicial systems and expanded social programs. Uruguay and Chile stand as examples of resilient democracies, maintaining strong institutions despite regional headwinds. Brazil’s massive electoral system and anti-corruption efforts demonstrate potential paths forward, though significant work remains.

The path ahead requires addressing fundamental challenges: protecting press freedom, strengthening judicial independence, and reducing economic disparities. Success depends on building transparent institutions that serve public interests rather than private gains, while ensuring equal protection under the law for all citizens, particularly vulnerable populations.

References

–https://thedialogue.org/analysis/the-rule-of-law-in-latin-america-from-constitutionalism-to-political-uncertainty/https://www.uruguayxxi.gub.uy/en/news/article/uruguay-is-the-fullest-democracy-in-south-america-and-ranks-14th-in-the-world/https://www.amnesty.org/en/location/americas/report-americas/https://minorityrights.org/country/colombia/https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/new-atlanticist/how-can-latin-america-halt-its-democratic-backsliding-and-how-can-the-us-help/https://www.journalofdemocracy.org/articles/books-in-review-comparing-latin-democracies/https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Voter-Turnout-Latin-America-by-country_tbl4_286345073https://www.as-coa.org/articles/chart-deep-dive-voter-turnout-latin-americahttps://www.transparency.org/en/news/political-integrity-lacking-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean-especially-ahttps://garymarks.web.unc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/13018/2022/07/2022_martinez-gallardo-et-al_revisiting-party-system-structuration-in-LA-and-Europe-1.pdfhttps://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-cost-of-democracy-campaign-finance-regulation-in-latin-america/https://www.idea.int/publications/catalog/state-political-finance-regulations-latin-americahttps://www.ohchr.org/en/countries/americas-region/un-human-rights-in-south-americahttps://rsf.org/en/region/americashttps://www.hrw.org/news/2022/01/13/latin-america-alarming-reversal-basic-freedomshttps://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2022/698868/EPRS_BRI(2022)698868_EN.pdfhttps://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-rapidly-deteriorating-quality-of-democracy-in-latin-america/https://www.csis.org/analysis/inflection-point-challenges-facing-latin-america-and-us-policy-regionhttps://www.imf.org/en/Blogs/Articles/2017/09/21/corruption-in-latin-america-taking-stockhttps://www.worldbank.org/en/results/2024/06/04/social-protection-programs-latin-america-and-caribbean